In three related actions before the Eastern District of New
York, consumer plaintiffs who purchased moist toilet wipes
manufactured and produced by Kimberly-Clark and sold by Costco
alleged that defendants mislabeled the wipes as
"flushable." The court denied certification of a
nationwide class, but did certify three New York class actions all
involving New York law and New York purchases but different
defendants and a different product.
The court declined to certify the nationwide class because the
named plaintiff failed to demonstrate the "financial or other
capacity to adequately represent a national class of
consumers." The court based this decision on plaintiff's
"reluctance to conduct a scientific survey of consumers to
determine a reasonable consumer's understanding of the term
'flushable'" and that "conducting such a survey
on a national scale would be costly." The court further found
limiting certification to New York classes appropriate because
"the events