On Wednesday, May 14, 2020, the United States Supreme Court
unanimously held that the doctrine of defense preclusion does not
apply in a case between two parties when the earlier case between
the parties involved different marks and different conduct
occurring at different times. Lucky Brand Dungarees Inc. v.
Marcel Fashions Group Inc., Case No. 18-1086, ___ U.S. ___
(May 14, 2020).
Lucky Brand Dungarees, Inc. ("Lucky Brand") sells
jeans and other clothing, as does Marcel Fashions Group, Inc.
("Marcel"). Both use the word "lucky" as a
component of their marks. Lucky Brand began selling LUCKY BRAND
clothing (and also began using other marks that include the term
"lucky" with clothing) in 1990, four years after Marcel
obtained a federal registration for use of the mark GET LUCKY for
use with clothing. The companies have been litigating almost ever
since.