Yesterday, we demonstrated that while affirmances generally are
pending longer in California from grant of review to argument to
decision, the evidence is more equivocal in Illinois, at least on
the civil side. Today, we look at the criminal side of the
docket. So, does there appear to be any correlation between
the final result and the lag time in criminal cases?
Our data contains 128 affirmances and 136 reversals between 2010
and 2016. From allowance of the petition for leave to appeal
to oral argument, criminal cases which ended in affirmance averaged
260.38 days, while reversals averaged 288.06 days.
We report the data from oral argument to decision in Table 448
below. For affirmances, the average time from argument to
decision is 122.84 days. For reversals, the average is 140.43
days. So, it turns out that for three of our four measures
(grant to argument and argument to decision for civil and
criminal), reversals took longer over a seven year