Rule 272 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure requires
objections to the charge to be made before the charge is read to
the jury. All objections not timely made are waived. Can a trial
court set an earlier deadline for charge objections? That was the
issue before the Texas Supreme Court in King Fisher Marine
Service, LP v. Tamez, 2014 Tex. LEXIS 776 (Tex. Aug. 29,
2014).
In that case, after the close of the evidence, the morning after
the formal charge conference and minutes before the trial court
would read the charge to the jury, the defendant made a last-minute
objection to the charge and proposed an instruction.
The trial court refused the instruction "mainly because
it's not timely," adding that "we needed to have all
this stuff done and in by yesterday." The defendant argued
that the trial court abused its discretion by disallowing the
proposed instruction. The Court of Appeals disagreed, concluding
that the trial court afforded the defendant ample