I saw an interesting item in the Wall Street Journal Law Blog
today.
Chief Judge Kozinski of the United States
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit appears to have invented
a whole new type of opinion.
Everyone has heard of majority opinions, dissents, and
concurrences.
But what does one do when the opinion of the en banc court is
hopelessly fractured, and one does not even think the court
asked the right question, let alone managed to divine the correct
answer.
Do what Chief Judge Kozinski did.
After the jump, the simplicity of "Going Vinny."
There is a certain grace and dignity in simplicity. And
honestly, who really counts noses when the court issues an alphabet
soup of competing opinions.