On January 31, 2020, Chief United States District Judge Kimberly
J. Mueller enjoined California from enforcing AB 51. This
new legislation prohibits employers from requiring their employees
to sign arbitration agreements. Last week, the court issued its detailed written opinion explaining the basis
for its decision.
As we predicted, the Court found that AB 51 is preempted by the
Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) because it "singles out
arbitration by placing uncommon barriers on employers who require
contractual waivers of dispute resolution options that bear the
defining features of arbitration." In short, AB 51 places
arbitration agreements on "unequal footing" as compared
to other contracts because AB 51's prohibition on California
employers' use of "right, forum, or procedure"
waivers as a condition of employment illegally disfavors
arbitration agreements.