Most people think an appeal begins when the losing party files a Notice of Appeal. In reality, the success of an appeal is often determined months, or even years, before that document is ever filed.
That may sound surprising, but appellate courts do not hear new testimony, consider new evidence, or decide who they believe. Instead, they review the record created in the trial court to determine whether legal errors occurred and whether those errors affected the outcome of the case.
For that reason, the foundation of a successful appeal is often laid while the underlying lawsuit is still being litigated.
Appeals Are Won (or Lost) on the Record
One of the most common misconceptions about appeals is that they provide an opportunity to start over. They do not.