In two recent cases, California and Florida district courts
reached divergent views on whether to permit wide-ranging class
discovery prior to a certification decision. Interestingly, both
decisions involved Ocwen companies. In Weiner, a RICO
class action, the class plaintiffs sought discovery of
defendants' "internal communications relating to their
decision to spin-off" a subsidiary because those
communications ostensibly bore on "classwide intent to
fraudulently conceal marked-up default-related costs from
consumers." The court rightly recognized that this discovery
really went to the merits, not class issues. It accordingly denied
the plaintiffs' motion to compel.
In Fegadel, however, a day later, a Florida court
granted in large part a motion to compel wide-ranging discovery in
a Florida Consumer Collection Practices Act claim. The plaintiff
alleged that a related Ocwen company improperly sought to collect
debt from consumers who had received a discharge in