New York, N.Y. (August 21, 2023) – New
York Appellate Associate Dean Pillarella recently authored an
article for theNew York Law Journal(part ofLaw.com)
titled, "A Fatal Attraction: 'Aho' Meets
'Bonczar,'" which discusses whetherand whenthe entry
of final judgment renders an interlocutory order denying summary
judgment unreviewable.
Mr. Pillarella opens the article byidentifyinga
"Catch-22" present in New Yorkprocedural law. He
explains, "The CPLR promises an appeal to any party denied
summary judgment on the merits. However, once final judgment is
entered, any interlocutory appeal is dismissed, and the denial of
summary judgment is rendered unreviewable on the ground that it
does not 'necessarily affect' the final judgment." Mr.
Pillarella observes, "This cannot be what the CPLR's
drafters envisioned as 'the just, speedy and inexpensive
determination of every civil proceeding.'"