The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and most state court rules
memorialize their basic work product doctrine in just one sentence.
But courts take divergent views on what that sentence means.
Some courts apply work product protection only to documents that
litigants will use to "assist" in litigation. Other
courts protect documents created "because of" the
litigation, even though they will not be used to "assist"
in that litigation. In Deutsche Bank National Trust Co. v. WMC
Mortgage, LLC, the court noted that under Second Circuit
precedent "the phrase 'because of' trumps 'assist
in' as the talisman by which a document's eligibility for
attorney work product protection will be evaluated." Nos.
3:12-CV-933, -969, -1699, & 3:13-CV-1347 (CSH), 2015 U.S. Dist.
LEXIS 49158, at *37-38 (D. Conn. Apr. 14, 2015). Three days later,
in Byman v. Angelica Textile Services, Inc. (In re
Sadler Clinic, PLLC), the court took the same approach —
noting that "[n]umerous courts of