Under the majority view, the only client agents/consultants
inside privilege protection are those essential for the
client-lawyer communications. Although courts take a more varied
view of lawyer agents/consultants, many courts hold that the only
lawyer agents within privilege protection are those essentially
translating or interpreting data so the lawyer can understand
it.
In Cardinal Aluminum Co. v. Continental Casualty Co.,
Case No. 3:14-CV-857-TBR-LLK, 2015 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 95361 (W.D. Ky.
July 22, 2015), the court held that plaintiff's insurance
broker was outside privilege protection — despite the
plaintiff's CFO's affidavit that the plaintiff relied on
the broker to submit an insurance claim, negotiate with the
insurance company, and advise the plaintiff about the claims
process. Among other things, the court noted that "Plaintiff
did not argue that its broker acted to effectuate legal
representation for Plaintiff." Id. at *8. About three
weeks earlier,