Chicago, Ill., (January 28, 2019) – The
appellate courts in Illinois may be trending toward a broader
definition of circumstantial evidence in slip and fall cases.
In a 2015 case involving an Illinois home improvement center, a
plaintiff claimed that she had slipped and fallen on ice in the
parking lot. There were no witnesses to the fall and the plaintiff
testified she had no idea where the ice had come from or how long
it had existed.
Based on this testimony, the court granted the defendant’s
request for summary judgment. The plaintiff appealed, claiming
photographic evidence of a wooden box containing liquid and/or used
to collect liquid draining from a downspout on the store’s
roof, taken some time after the occurrence, presented
circumstantial evidence that a store employee placed the box at the
store entrance. Further, the plaintiff claimed that, at some point,
the liquid leaked from the box downhill to the parking lot where it
eventually froze in the exact