A restaurant tells customers it may sue them if they post
unfavorable reviews on the Internet. A flooring company sues a
customer who complained on social media that he had an
"absolutely horrible experience" with the company.
Klear-Gear, a gadget company, included in its Internet terms a
provision that "your acceptance of this sales contract
prohibits you from taking any action that negatively impacts
KlearGear.com, its reputation, products, services, management or
expenses." The terms also set damages for a violation:
$3,500.
If something seems wrong to you about these cases, you are not
alone. While libel law has struggled for years with the dividing
line between expressions of actionable fact and constitutionally
protected opinion, most laypeople, and judges, believe that
statements of opinion should be protected, and broadly
construed.