In most situations, a client's denial that an
attorney-client communication occurred does not waive the
client's privilege. Such a denial clearly does not disclose any
privileged communications. And if such a denial waived the
privilege, it is easy to envision a clever adversary creating
mischief by asking deposition questions that would elicit
denials.
However, a different rule applies if the client seeks some
advantage by denying that a privileged communication occurred. In
Adam Friedman Assocs. LLC v. MediaG3, Inc., No. 10 Civ.
5350 (JPO), 2012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 62591 (S.D.N.Y. May 1, 2012),
Judge Oetken dealt with a client's effort to vacate the
court's earlier entry of summary judgment against it. The
client argued that its previous lawyer had never advised it to
oppose the summary judgment motion. The court found that the client
had "directly put at issue the question [of] whether it
received notice from its former attorney," so it would be
"unfair" for the