Unlike work product protection, attorney-client privilege
protection normally requires a "communication" between a
client and a lawyer. To be sure, the privilege can protect (1) a
client's communication intended for a lawyer, but which has not
yet arrived; (2) a client's uncommunicated memorialization of a
privileged communication; or (3) communications among joint clients
or among employees of a corporate client formulating a request for
legal advice or relaying a lawyer's legal advice. However,
clients frequently have difficulty establishing the applicability
of the privilege protection in those rare circumstances.
In Graves v. Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc., No. 07
Civ. 5471 (BSJ)(KNF), 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 140429 (S.D.N.Y. Dec.
5, 2011), Judge Jones refused to protect notes prepared by an age
discrimination plaintiff. The court noted that the plaintiff's
privilege log "does not indicate that the notes were actually
communicated to counsel, but merely that they