Whales may be rare, but even rarer is a USPTO quadrifusal! The
Office refused to register four marks comprising or containing the
term PACIFIC WHALE FOUNDATION for promotional,
educational, fundraising, and research services in the field of
marine wildlife conservation [FOUNDATION disclaimed] on the ground
that Applicant failed to comply with a requirement that it disclaim
WHALE FOUNDATION. The Examining Attorney, citing dictionary
definitions and third-party registrations, maintained that WHALE
FOUNDATION is the generic name of a specific sub-category of
Applicant's services. Applicant cited other third-party
registrations (e.g., AMERICAN HORSE FOUNDATION) in which
no similar disclaimer is found. How do you think this came out?
In re Pacific Whale Foundation, Serial Nos. 87891322,
87891333, 87891351, and 87891363 (December 18, 2020)[not
precedential] (Opinion by Judge George C. Pologeorgis).