Earlier in April, the PTAB designated as precedential or
informative five decisions relating to what evidence can show that
an asserted reference is a printed publication. On April 14, 2020,
the PTAB provided more guidance to practitioners by designating
three additional decisions as precedential or informative. All
three discussed how the Board weighs objective indicia of
non-obviousness.
Lectrosonics, Inc. v. Zaxcom,
Inc., Case IPR2018-01129, Paper 33 (Jan.
24, 2020) (precedential)
In an inter partes review, the patent owner defended
that objective indicia of nonobviousness, including long-felt need,
failure of others, and industry praise supported finding the claims
not unpatentable. The Board, however, found that the patent owner
did not provide an analysis that showed its products were
coextensive, or nearly coextensive, with the challenged claims.
Accordingly, the Board found no presumption of a nexus between
those products and the indicia of nonobviousness.