IP UPDATE: Edited by Paul Devinsky and Rita
Weeks
After a protracted investigation that involved two separate
appellate opinions, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit affirmed a final determination by the International Trade
Commission (ITC) that the asserted claims were invalid due to
obviousness. The underlying ITC investigation was initiated
when complainant Norgren filed a complaint in October 2006 alleging
a violation of Section 337 by respondent SMC based on the
infringement of a single patent. Norgren Inc. v.
Int'l Trade Comm'n, Case No. 11-1349 (Fed. Cir., Nov.
14, 2012) (Norgren II) (Linn, J.) (Moore, J.,
dissenting).
The patent at issue relates to structures that connect
fluid-conditioning units in a compressed air pipeline. The
administrative law judge (ALJ) assigned to the investigation
concluded that the accused connectors made by SMC did not infringe
the asserted patent, and the ITC declined to review that initial
determination. In