Since 2000, the Federal Circuit has routinely applied the Lead
Compound Analysis to assess the patentability of chemical
compounds. The Lead Compound Analysis is a two-part test used to
evaluate whether a claimed chemical compound would have been
obvious. This test considers:
- Whether a person of ordinary skill in the art would have had
reason to select a prior art compound as a "lead
compound" for further development; and
- Whether a person of ordinary skill would have been motivated to
modify the lead compound to make the claimed compound with a
reasonable expectation of success.
Where the Lead Compound Analysis is used, both prongs must be
satisfied to prove obviousness. This test, especially the first
prong, provides a unique tool for challenging and proving
obviousness in the chemical arts. This is particularly true at the
Federal Circuit, where the test originated, but the test is also
gaining traction at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB).