Raising the hurdle for proving secondary considerations, the US
Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit found that the
"coextensiveness" requirement for purposes of nexus
requires that the practicing product be "essentially the
claimed invention." FOX Factory, Inc. v. SRAM, LLC,
Case No. 18-2024, -2025 (Fed. Cir. Dec. 18, 2019) (Prost, J.).
Bicycle chainrings are the toothed disks to which bicycle chains
engage. SRAM owns a patent directed to an improved chainring
structure that better maintains the chain, obviating the need for
extraneous structures. The independent claims of the patent recite
a chainring with alternating narrow and wide tooth tips and teeth
offset from the center of the chainring. Some of the claims recite
tooth tips offset toward the body of the bicycle (inboard offsets)
and other claims recite teeth offset away from the body of the
bicycle (outboard offsets). The specification discloses additional
chainring features that are not recited in the