Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 17 MARCH 2014

Patentees Bear The Burden Of Proving Infringement In Declaratory Judgment Actions

In the recent case of Medtronic v. Mirowski, the Supreme Court held that "when a licensee seeks a declaratory judgment against a patentee to establish that there is no infringement, the burden of proving infringement remains with the patentee."

United StatesIntellectual Property

In the recent case of Medtronic v. Mirowski, the Supreme Court held that "when a licensee seeks a declaratory judgment against a patentee to establish that there is no infringement, the burden of proving infringement remains with the patentee." This decision extends the Court's MedImmune ruling, which allows licensees to challenge the validity and/or infringement of a patent without repudiating the underlying license.

The Medtronic decision unanimously reversed the Federal Circuit, framing the analysis as "simple legal logic, resting upon settled case law." The opinion reasoned that the burden of proof is a substantive aspect of a claim, which rests on a patentee in a patent infringement action, and therefore cannot be shifted to a licensee seeking declaratory judgment because declaratory judgment is "procedural," leaving substantive rights unchanged. Medtronic also found support in "practical considerations" that may not bode well for patentees.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from