In Spear Marketing, Inc. v. BancorpSouth Bank et al.,
__ F.3d __, 2015 WL 3972246 (5th Cir. June 30, 2015), the United
States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit joined the majority
of its sister circuits in finding that copying or theft of an idea
or non-copyrightable work fixed in a tangible medium is preempted
by federal copyright law. The issue was one of first impression for
the Fifth Circuit.
Spear Marketing, Inc. ("SMI") licensed its cash
management software VaultWorks to BancorpSouth Bank
("BancorpSouth") from 2002-2012. When BancorpSouth did
not renew its agreement with SMI and instead licensed a new cash
management software developed by ARGO Data Resource Corporation
("ARGO") (its teller software provider of 20 years), SMI
claimed the ARGO product was created by taking SMI's trade
secrets. SMI originally filed its case in Texas state court,
alleging misappropriation of trade secrets, fraud and breach of
contract, among other derivative causes of action.