The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (in a case
that attracted a dozen amici briefs) affirmed a district
court ruling by Circuit Judge Posner (sitting by designation) that
the holder of the FRAND-encumbered SEP patent in this case was not
entitled to injunctive relief, but insisted that there is no
per se rule covering such patents and that an
eBay analysis is nevertheless required.
In a closely watched case involving a high profile circuit court
judge sitting (by designation) at trial and raising the hot button
issue of whether the holder of a fair, reasonable and
non-discriminatory terms, or FRAND-encumbered standard essential
patent (SEP) was in essence barred from seeking injunctive relief,
the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (in a case that
attracted a dozen amici briefs) affirmed Judge
Posner's ruling that the holder of the FRAND-encumbered patent
in this case was not entitled to injunctive relief, but insisted
that an eBay analysis