On July 13, 2018, the Federal Circuit issued an opinion in
Polara Engineering v. Campbell Company, which has been
noticed for its discussion of enhanced damages. However, the
opinion is also notable for its discussion of experimental use to
negate the statutory public use bar. In particular, it
reminds us of a famous U.S. Supreme Court case on experimental use
that is a staple of our patent law textbooks: City of
Elizabeth v. American Nicholson Pavement Co. (U.S.
1877).
City of Elizabeth is memorable for its quoted testimony
of a road toll-collector, Mr. Joseph L. Lang. Mr. Lang
vividly described observing Mr. Nicholson's (sometimes spelled
"Nicolson") almost daily inspection of an installed test
section of his wooden road pavement invention: "he would
examine the pavement, would often walk over it, cane in hand,
striking it with his cane, and making particular examination of its
condition. He asked me very often how people liked it, and
asked me a great many