On December 22, 2022, Director Kathi Vidal issued a pair of
decisions in the OpenSky v. VLSI saga, dismissing OpenSky
Industries LLC ("OpenSky") and Patent Quality Assurance
LCC ("PQA") from their respective challenges of VLSI
patents at the heart of a multi-billon dollar jury award against
Intel. OpenSky Industries LLC v. VLSI Tech. LLC,
IPR2021-01064, Paper 121 (PTAB Dec. 22, 2022); Patent Quality
Assurance LLC v. VLSCI Tech. LLC, IPR2021-01229, Paper 102
(PTAB Dec. 22, 2022)(precedential).
Previously in her October 4, 2022 Director review decision (as
we covered here), Director Vidal found OpenSky had abused
the inter partes review ("IPR") process by
filing an IPR petition to extract settlement payment from both the
Patent Owner, VLSI, and joined Petitioner, Intel. Further, OpenSky
was found to have engaged in further sanctionable conduct including
discovery misconduct, violation of an express order, and unethical
conduct. As a result, Director Vidal precluded