As we noted here,
the PTAB recently designated two 35 U.S.C. § 325(d) cases
precedential and one informative. Here is an in depth review of the
informative decision.
On October 31, 2019, the PTAB denied PUMA
North America, Inc. (PUMA)'s petition for inter partes
review of claims 1-6 of Nike, Inc. (Nike)'s U.S. Patent
number 9,314,065 (the '065 patent) directed to a sports shoe
with cleats in IPR 2019-01042. On March 24, 2020, the PTAB
designated its opinion denying institution as Informative.
Nike's '065 patent discloses an article of footwear,
e.g., a cleated soccer shoe, designed to "optimize propulsion
during the first step of sprinting and provide stability and
responsiveness while also moderating stud pressure during quick
directional changes." '065 Patent at 1:6–17,
3:65–67, Fig. 1. Claim 1, the sole independent claim, is
directed to the structure of the baseplate of the article of
footwear.