While a donut with no hole may be a Danish, a photograph is not
publicly displayed if the public never sees it. And in photography
copyright cases, these near metaphysical questions matter.
VHT, a provider of real estate photographs, sued Zillow, the
real estate internet company, for copyright infringement. Zillow
obtains most of the photos it posts – up to 5 million per day
– through automated feeds from real estate agents and
multiple listing services. Some of them are VHT copyrighted
photographs.
VHT alleged that Zillow indirectly infringed its copyrights by
encouraging Zillow's website users to also upload VHT
photographs to Zillow Digs – an application where Zillow
pairs photographs it "digs" with advertisements for
products shown in the photos. That is, Zillow never posted the
photos on Zillow Digs unless a website user affirmatively directed
a posting.