A federal judge has dismissed claims that online services that
provided access to legal briefs filed in federal court were
infringing the copyright in those briefs.
Earlier this month, in one of the most highly watched copyright
cases of the last few years, Judge Rakoff of the Southern District
of New York issued a ruling dismissing the case brought against
Westlaw and LexisNexis by a pair of copyright attorneys. Westlaw
and LexisNexis both provide access to legal briefs filed in federal
cases, for a fee. The attorneys claimed that through this practice,
Westlaw and LexisNexis unlawfully profited from their copyrighted
works.
Judge Rakoff's summary ruling was not supported by an
extensive order including his reasoning, but he did promise a
future order discussing his rationale for dismissing the case.
Although the judge's reasoning is currently unknown, Westlaw
and LexisNexis argued that they were entitled to use the documents
under the fair use doctrine. The