In Chamberlain Group, Inc. v. One World
Technologies, Inc., No. 2018-2112 (Fed. Cir. Dec. 17,
2019), the Court addressed whether the Patent Trial
and Appeal Board acted appropriately in disregarding an argument
raised for the first time at the oral hearing.
In disputing the proper construction of a claim term in an inter
partes review, the petitioner, One World, advanced a new argument
for its claim construction for the first time in its reply
brief. The patent owner, Chamberlain, responded to that
argument at its first possible opportunity: the oral hearing.
In the final written decision, the Board held that Chamberlain had
waived its argument because the argument was not briefed and, per
the Trial Practice Guide, new evidence or arguments may not be
presented at the oral hearing.