Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 17 FEBRUARY 2022

Texas Supreme Court Clarifies "Eight-Corners" Rule Exception For Insurers

In a pair of recent cases, the Texas Supreme Court announced that the duty-to-defend "eight-corners" rule is not absolute and set a new standard on when extrinsic evidence can be considered.

United StatesInsurance

In a pair of recent cases, the Texas Supreme Court announced that the duty-to-defend "eight-corners" rule is not absolute and set a new standard on when extrinsic evidence can be considered.

For years, courts have diverged on whether Texas law permits one to look beyond the "eight corners" of the underlying petition and policy to determine whether an insurer owes a duty to defend an insured. Federal courts, guided by the  Fifth Circuit's "Erie guess" on how the Texas Supreme Court would rule, have considered extrinsic evidence "when it is initially impossible to discern whether coverage is potentially implicated and when the extrinsic evidence goes solely to a fundamental issue of coverage which does not overlap with the merits of or engage the truth or falsity of any facts alleged in the underlying case." Many courts, including some Texas state courts, have adopted this exception, known as the "Northfield exception." However, many others have rejected it on the

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from