The federal policy favoring arbitration sometimes bumps up
against state-based receivers where the receiver would rather the
receivership court address reinsurance disputes than have the
matter arbitrated. In the aftermath of Hurricanes Irma and Maria,
which devastated Puerto Rico, reinsurance disputes arose over a
cedent’s allocation between the hurricanes and other aspects
of the many claims ceded to reinsurers. In an anticipated ruling,
the question of whether these disputes will be arbitrated or
resolved in the receivership court has been answered.
In Integrand Assurance Co. v. Everest Reinsurance
Co., No. 19-1111 (DRD) (D. P.R. Dec. 4, 2019), an
insolvent cedent sought to invalidate the arbitration clause in
several reinsurance agreements with several reinsurers and force
the reinsurance disputes over Hurricane Irma and Maria claims into
the state court governing the cedent’s liquidation
proceedings. The reinsurers, who all had the same or similar
arbitration