A federal district court remanded a suit that was removed on the
basis that independent adjusters were improperly joined to defeat
diversity finding that the plaintiff had stated claims against the
adjusters upon which relief could be granted. Lillie Jean Hooper v.
Allstate Texas Lloyd’s, et al., 2017 WL 4475931 (S.D. Tex.
Oct. 6, 2017).
An insured sued her insurer and two adjusters for storm damage
to her home. The two adjusters inspected the property and reported
no storm damage. The insurer removed the case asserting improper
joinder of the adjusters who were Texas residents.
The court noted that there are two grounds for improper joinder,
namely, fraud in the pleadings or an inability of the plaintiff to
establish a cause of action against the non-diverse party. The test
for fraudulent joinder is whether the defendant has demonstrated
that there is no reasonable basis for the court to predict that the
plaintiff might be able to recover against the in-state