Few provisions in Directors and Officers ("D&O")
insurance policies have given rise to more litigation than the
personal profit exclusion. For those unfamiliar, the provision
generally excludes coverage for claims arising from or based upon
the gaining of any personal profit, advantage or remuneration to
which an insured was not legally entitled. Insurers
typically allege that this exclusion applies broadly to D&O
lawsuits that allege an act of wrongdoing leading, directly or
incidentally, to the company receiving some profit or advantage.
Compounding the issue, the personal profit exclusion, unlike other
conduct-related exclusions (e.g., the "fraud
exclusion"), does not require culpability or ill-motive.
According to insurers' thinking, the clause excludes coverage
for virtually all D&O lawsuits. Indeed, the potential reach of
the personal profit exclusion seems bound only by the imaginations
of creative insurers seeking to deny coverage.