This week, the Court addresses the constitutionality of a nearly
$1 billion statutory damages award under the Telephone Consumer
Protection Act (TCPA) and revives a California state law
whistleblower claim.
The Court holds a defendant waived reliance on the FCC's
retroactive exemption and remands for the district court to assess
the constitutionality of a nearly $1 billion statutory damages
award.
The panel: Judges Berzon, Tallman, and
Christen, with Judge Tallman writing the opinion.
Key highlight: "Constitutional limits on
aggregate statutory damages awards therefore must be reserved for
circumstances in which a largely punitive per-violation amount
results in an aggregate that is gravely disproportionate to and
unreasonably related to the legal violation committed. Were that
not so, applying the Williams test to reduce aggregated
statutory awards would overstep the role of the judiciary and usurp
the power of the legislature."