One of the ways that President Obama tried to restrict the
influence of lobbyists in Washington was to ban all registered
lobbyists from serving on federal advisory committees. A group of
lobbyists who wanted to serve on some Industry Trade Advisory
Committees ("ITAC"), a specific type of federal advisory
committee, sued the administration. They argued that the government
was infringing on their constitutionally protected right to lobby.
The trial court rejected their arguments and dismissed the
case.
Undeterred, the lobbyists appealed. The D.C. Circuit reversed the lower court's decision and
remanded the case for further factual development and analysis. On
remand, the district court will have to evaluate whether the
government can justify its decision to exclude lobbyists from the
ITACs. This balancing test will require the court to look at the
interests of the individuals affected by the ban versus the
interests set forth by the government. The court said that