ISDA analyzed the use of uncleared margin for derivatives as an
incentive to clear. In a new
white paper that draws on internal research, ISDA concludes, among other things, that: (i)
initial margin ("IM") for uncleared derivatives should
not be required for counterparties that pose little or no systemic
risk and (ii) the role of margin as a clearing incentive should be
reconsidered, given other incentives to clear.
With this paper, ISDA seeks to answer two questions: (1) does
the scope of the existing IM requirements for uncleared derivatives
appropriately achieve the goal of reducing systemic risk, and (2)
does the margining of uncleared derivatives incentivize
clearing?ISDA essentially answers both of these questions in the
negative.