On August 29, 2019, an Illinois court denied a petition by a
political activist and a hedge fund seeking leave to file a lawsuit
claiming that approximately $16 billion of Illinois’s general
obligation bonds (“GO Bonds”)
were issued in violation of the state constitution.1 Judge Jack D. Davis, II, sitting in a
circuit court in the state capital of Springfield, held that the
challenged bonds did not violate a provision of the Illinois
Constitution requiring long-term debt to be for a “specific
purpose,” because the legislation authorizing the issuances
had, in fact, “stated with reasonable detail the specific
purposes for the issuance of the bonds.”2 Judge Davis also held more broadly that
the validity of the bond issuances constituted “a
non-justiciable political question” such that for a court to
rule on the issue “would be improper and would violate the
separation of powers.”3 Given the breadth of the
ruling, it seems likely that Judge Davis wanted to preclude