In a fascinating decision issued today, the
D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals struck down EPA's Summit
Directive. The Summit Directive – sounds ominous – was
issued in response to the 2012 decision in
Summit Petroleum Corp. v. EPA, in which the Sixth Circuit Court
of Appeals ruled that EPA could not consider two facilities as
"adjacent" for Title V and NSR permitting purposes unless
they are, in fact, adjacent. EPA had previously interpreted
facilities as adjacent based in part on whether the facilities,
even if not physically adjacent, were "functionally
interrelated."
Following the decision in Summit, EPA determined that it would
continue to apply the broader definition of "adjacent" at
facilities located outside the Sixth Circuit. It then issued
the Summit Directive documenting that position. The National
Environmental Development Association sued, arguing that the result
of the Summit Directive was that its clients located outside the
Sixth Circuit are at a