Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 14 FEBRUARY 2014

The States Lose Another NSR (And NSPS) Enforcement Case: I Think I Detect A Trend

As I have previously noted, the government’s record in NSR enforcement cases has been going downhill, particularly with important defeats before the 3rd and 7th Circuits’ Courts of Appeals.

United StatesEnvironment

As I have previously noted, the government's record in NSR enforcement cases has been going downhill, particularly with important defeats before the 3rd and 7th Circuits' Courts of Appeals.  The latest governmental defeat came late last week, in Pennsylvania v. Allegheny Energy, when Chief Judge Conti granted judgment for the defendants on claims alleging both NSR and NSPS violations.

At some level, the decision is not a big surprise, since the court had previously ruled in Allegheny's favor on the critical legal issue, concluding that whether projects constitute "routine maintenance, repair, and replacement", or RMRR, must be based on whether the project is routine in the industry, not routine for the particular facility that is the subject of the enforcement action.  The Court was also bound by the prior 3rd Circuit ruling in Homer City that was favorable to Allegheny Energy on the statute of limitations issue, making clear that PSD review is a one-time

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from