The Supreme Court's 2013 term just began but it is already
shaping up to be an important one for power plant owners and
operators. Three points stand out: First, on October 7, the
Court denied cert. in Luminant Generation Co. LLC v. EPA, a case in
which several power companies were challenging the Environmental
Protection Agency's (EPA) current approach to regulating air
emissions during startup, shutdown and malfunction (SSM)
events. The Court's action leaves in place a Fifth
Circuit decision which upheld EPA's approach, at least as
applied to the Clean Air Act state implementation plan (SIP) for
the State of Texas. More importantly, the Court's action
is likely to bolster EPA's confidence as it pursues its ongoing
rulemaking concerning the SSM provisions in 39 other SIPs, a
rulemaking in which EPA has proposed eliminating affirmative
defenses for excess emissions that occur during "planned"
SSM events. More information about EPA's ongoing SSM
rulemaking can be