It is proving very difficult for plaintiffs to survive a motion
to dismiss, let alone obtain judicial relief associated with the
alleged results of climate change.
Earlier this week, on May 20, 2013, the Supreme Court of the
United States
denied certiorari to plaintiffs in the Native Village
of Kivalina lawsuit against various "energy companies."
The plaintiffs were appealing the
Ninth Circuit's dismissal of Kivalina's claims for
damages under a federal common law claim of public nuisance, which
the court held were displaced by the federal Clean Air Act.
Earlier this month, on May 14, 2013, the Fifth Circuit, in Comer v. Murphy Oil USA, ended the
plaintiffs' suit against various "energy companies"
that were allegedly responsible for the damages associated with
Hurricane Katrina. This class action lawsuit of Mississippi
residents had an unusual procedural path and was recently dismissed
on procedural grounds, but this action left the prior substantive
decision