The Sixth District Court of Appeal held that the undefined terms
"in-fill development" and "substantially surrounded
by urban uses" in the CEQA exemption for in-fill development
were not limited by the definitions of similar terms in other parts
of the CEQA statute and guidelines. Working Families of
Monterey County v. King City Planning Commission, 106
Cal.App.5th 833 (2024).
The King City Planning Commission approved a Grocery Outlet
project after determining that it qualified for the CEQA class 32
categorical exemption for projects on infill development.
Petitioners challenged the project's approval arguing that the
project did not qualify for an exemption because it was located in
a rural area and not "substantially surrounded by urban
uses" as required by the CEQA guidelines. Petitioners claimed
that because "in-fill development" or "substantially
surrounded by urban uses" are not defined, those terms must be
interpreted by the definitions for "in-fill