In early 1999, the Venetian Casino Resort in Las Vegas asked
police officers to remove union protesters from a temporary walkway
in front of the Venetian — a walkway the Venetian built on
its property in exchange for the public expansion of the Las Vegas
Strip to accommodate increased vehicular traffic.
Eventually, the Ninth Circuit determined that the walkway was a
public forum, so the Venetian had no property right to exclude
them. In turn, the unions behind the protest filed an unfair
labor practice charge challenging, among other things, the
Venetian's request that the police remove the protestors from
the walkway (even though the police did not oblige). The
Venetian responded that its request was protected by the Petition
Clause of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution (which
protects "the right of the people . . . to petition the
Government for a redress of grievances") and therefore could
not be a violation of the National Labor Relations