The Eight Circuit recently addressed this question in Ag Spectrum Co. v. Elder, Case No.
16-3113 (8th Cir. August 2, 2017). In that case, Ag Spectrum
contracted with Vaughn Elder to work as an independent contractor.
Elder also agreed to a three-year noncompete whereby he would not
compete with Ag Spectrum by "marketing to, selling to, or
consulting with its customers about similar products for three
years after terminating the Agreement." Elder argued that the
Agreement was unenforceable under Iowa law.
The Eighth Circuit agreed, affirming the lower court's
decision finding the noncompete unenforceable. Notably, the Eighth
Circuit did not hold that noncompete provisions with
independent contractors are unenforceable per se,
expressly rejecting Elder's argument. Rather, the Court engaged
in a fact-intensive inquiry determining that the noncompete was
unreasonable under Iowa law. For one, the noncompete was
unnecessary to protect Ag Spectrum's business. Elder did