Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 01 MARCH 2014

"Extreme Deference" In ERISA Disability Claims Has Its Limits

Less than a month ago, the Sixth Circuit reaffirmed that the arbitrary and capricious standard of review under ERISA is "extremely deferential," pushing back on attempts by plaintiffs to erode the level of deference given to plan administrators (see our January 31, 2014 review of McClain v. Eaton Corporation Disability Plan, et al.).

United StatesEmployment and HR

Less than a month ago, the Sixth Circuit reaffirmed that the arbitrary and capricious standard of review under ERISA is "extremely deferential," pushing back on attempts by plaintiffs to erode the level of deference given to plan administrators ( see our January 31, 2014 review of McClain v. Eaton Corporation Disability Plan, et al.). On February 13, 2014, in Kennard v. Means Industries, Inc., a panel of the Sixth Circuit concluded that even extreme deference has its limits, reversing a ruling by the Eastern District of Michigan in favor of an employer's disability retirement plan.

Kyle Kennard worked for Means Industries as a machine operator until 1990, when he inhaled chemical fumes and severely injured his lungs, rendering him "ultra-sensitive" to various fumes and able to work only in a "clean-air environment." He performed clerical work for Means until 2006, apparently because Means could not provide him with a complete "clean-air" work environment. Kennard

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from