From time to time you may see ERISA benefit claimants seeking
declarations from the Court regarding "future
benefits."
But there is that old rule, recently recognized again,
that such claims should be dismissed because there is no "live
case or controversy."
To highlight this point, here's the recent case of Peer v. Liberty Life Assurance
Co.., __ Fed. Appx. __ (11th Cir. February 8,
2019)("Absent an adverse benefits determination, there is no
ripe claim before us.")
FACTS: Peer brought a claim for ERISA-governed
life insurance benefits. She sought (1) a ruling
enforcing the Waiver of Premium benefit (this allows a covered
person who become "Totally Disabled" while insured to
remain eligible for coverage without paying premiums); and
(2) a declaration as to "future eligibility
of benefits—whether and how [Liberty] will handle her waiver
of premium requests in the future."