Today, we're concluding our review of Justice Liu's
patterns in oral argument with a look at the criminal cases
he's participated in.
You'll recall that Justice Liu did not follow the usual
pattern even when in the majority in civil cases – he
questioned the respondent more heavily regardless of the eventual
result. The data for criminal cases is similar. When in the
majority of an affirmance, he has averaged 1.79 questions to
respondents and 0.88 to appellants. When he joins the majority
reversing, he averages 2.77 questions to respondents and 2.15 to
appellants. When he joins the majority in a split decision –
affirmed in part, reversed in part – he averages 2.03
questions to respondents and 1.26 to appellants.