Recent decisions from the Second, Sixth, Seventh, and Ninth circuits, as well as California appellate courts, confirm a consistent rule: online terms are enforceable when users receive reasonably conspicuous notice of the terms and take an action that clearly manifests assent. Courts have applied this rule through a granular, interface-focused analysis, producing a developing body of considerations for online contract formation.
Below is a synthesis of key holdings showing what courts have accepted — and rejected — as sufficient notice and assent.
Design Practices Courts Have Enforced
Courts have consistently enforced online terms where the interface tightly couples clear, proximate disclosure with an affirmative action that signals agreement. Accordingly, stakeholders may wish to take the following actions: