In a sudden reversal and after more than more than five years of
uncertainty, on May 23, 2019, the Supreme Court of Florida ruled
that Daubert – not Frye – now governs
the admissibility of expert testimony in Florida. See
In re Amendments to the Florida Evidence
Code, No. SC19-107, May 23, 2019.
Prior to 1993, the Frye standard for admitting expert
testimony was the prevailing standard used to guide federal and
state courts regarding the admissibility of scientific expert
testimony at trial. Frye v. United States. The
Frye standard required that the proponent of the evidence
establish the general acceptance of the underlying scientific
principle and the testing procedures. However, in 1993, following a
revision to the Federal Evidence Code by Congress, the Supreme
Court of the United States set forth a new standard in Daubert
v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc. that was meant to be more
flexible and focused on scientific principles and methodology
rather than on