Albert Nigro just wanted to turn off his deceased
mother-in-law's electricity. He called the electric company,
but it required that he provide his mobile telephone number to
disconnect service. It turned out though that the mother-in-law had
an outstanding bill of $68. Nigro did not know about that when he
gave his number. He was not legally required to pay it.
The electric company hired a debt collector to recover the $68
owing on the mother-in-law's account. The debt collector placed
72 autodial calls over the course of nine months to Nigro. In each
call, the message asked for the mother-in-law. Eventually, Nigro
had enough. He sued under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. He
argued that while he had voluntarily given his number in connection
with disconnecting his mother-in-law's service, he had not
given consent for calls about an outstanding debt. The debt
collector argued, based on prior Federal Communications Commission
rulings, that providing a phone